How to Get Craigslist Long Island Free Stuff (Faster)

Craigslist is a popular American company located in the city of San Francisco, CA. It is a classified advertisement website.

The company was founded in 1995 by Craig Newmark as an email distribution list for friends. and later became a web-based service in 1996.

Thereafter, it expanded into different classified categories. Today, Craigslist operates in more than 70 countries.

The website has different sections, and each section is devoted to a specific category of item or service, as well as discussion forums.

There is also a section on the Craigslist website dedicated to free listings of stuff. In the free section, all free kinds of stuff are listed according to states and cities.

In this guide, you’ll learn how to get Craigslist free stuff in Long Island. This guide is based on my personal experience and the tricks I have used to get free stuff on Craigslist in Long Island.

Why You Don’t Get Free Stuff on Craigslist in Long Island

If you live in the city of Long Island, a densely populated island in southeastern New York State,

You must have tried a couple of times to get free stuff on Craigslist in the city, but maybe you never succeeded.

If so, you may be making one of the following mistakes:

Below are some of the reasons you don’t get free stuff on Craigslist on Long Island:

1. You may be sending spam to advertisers.

While spending some vacation time in this city, I noticed that a few friends here on Long Island have continuously made this very mistake.

If you want to get anything free, you have to try and make sure your email subject and body to the poster do not look or sound spammy because it triggers suspicion.

When you want to email anyone who posts free stuff on Craigslist, try as much as possible to make your email sound natural and not spammy.

2. Always include a phone number.

If you email an advertiser and request to get their free stuff without including your phone number,

There is a high probability that the advertiser will not take you seriously and may see you as an unserious fellow or not a real person.

3. Late response to the ad

Many people on Long Island are also looking for free stuff, just like you. So for this reason, you need to be fast in responding to such free listings on Craigslist.

This is because the advertisement is in the public domain, and the faster you respond to it, the better your chances.

To get notice of free stuff posted on Craigslist, you need to set up a Google alert to monitor your target keyword.

Craigslist Long Island Free Stuff

How to Get Craigslist Free Stuff on Long Island

There are a few tricks you need to apply if you want to buy pieces of stuff on Craigslist.

Here is how to increase your chances of getting free stuff on Craigslist in Long Island:

  1. Go to
  2. Email as quickly as you can.
  3. Sound Natural
  4. Put your phone number
  5. Send a Thank-You Message

1. Go to

When you’re on the page, search for free stuff. To increase your chances of getting a free listing on Craigslist, it is recommended that you look for the latest postings.

When you see what you want, contact the advertiser and tell him or her your interest in the item.

2. Email as quickly as you can.

If you want to get good stuff from Craigslist’s free listings, you’ll have to email the advertisers as quickly as possible.

Your emails should look like human responses, not some automated crap.

Here is what the email should look like: We’ll be using a gray sofa as an example.


Hello, I’m interested in your gray loveseat.


Hi, my name is Courtenay, and I live here in Queens County. I just saw your ad on Craigslist a few minutes ago. for a free leather sofa and sofa bed couch kind of stuff, and my husband and I would like to come over and pick it up today if that’s okay with you, or anytime you may wish is better.

Here is my phone number: 972-897-2825. Feel free to reach out to me anytime.

Thank you

3. Sound natural.

You will have to sound as natural as you can to avoid looking spammy.

There are a lot of spammers on Craigslist, and people got pissed off with such

So make sure your email to the advertiser is personalized, as in the sample above, to further increase your chances of getting the item.

4. Put your phone number

Make sure to put your phone number at the end of the email to enable the advertiser to contact you.

Please include a phone number, not an email address. People have more confidence talking to a real person on the phone than via email.

Your phone number will further prove you’re not just a spammer or some kind of crazy person trying to market an affiliate item.

5. Send a Thank You Message

Once you have successfully picked up the item from the advertiser,

In your free time later that same day, try to send a thank-you message to the advertiser who just gave you something for free.

People in this commercial city welcome feedback and reviews, so try to send a thank-you message as feedback to the advertiser.

Bottom Line

Getting free Craigslist stuff in Long Island and counties like Brooklyn, Queens, and Nassau is not as challenging as people make it look.

What I have noticed with many people in Long Island and nearby cities who have tried getting real stuff on Craigslist but couldn’t is that they didn’t follow the right steps.

So if you’re in Long Island and you want a free item on Craigslist, I encourage you to follow the tips listed above, and you can be sure to get any free items on Craigslist.

Further Reading

How to Get Craigslist Orlando Free Stuff (Faster) 

Recent Articles

Related Stories

Stay on op - Ge the daily news in your inbox